Here are the New Jersey private schools that made the list: (The numbers in parentheses are where the schools that ranked among the top 100 in America finished):
- The Lawrenceville School, Lawrenceville (3rd best in America)
- Newark Academy, Livingston (49th best in America)
- The Pingry School, Martinsville (55th in America)
- Peddie School, Hightstown (64th in America)
- Delbarton School, Morristown (82nd best in America)
- Princeton Day School, Princeton (89th best in America)
- The Montclair Kimberley Academy, Montclair
- Dwight-Englewood School, Englewood
- Collegiate School, Passaic
- Kent Place School, Summit
- Blair Academy, Blairstown
- Rutgers Preparatory School, Somerset
- The Hun School of Princeton, Princeton
- Stuart Country Day School, Princeton
- Gill St. Bernard’s School, Gladstone
- Ranney School, Tinton Falls
- The Pennington School, Pennington
- Villa Walsh Academy, Morristown
- The Hudson School, Hoboken
- Wardlaw-Hartridge School, Edison
- Moorestown Friends School, Moorestown
- Oak Knoll School of the Holy Child, Summit
- Oratory Preparatory School, Summit
- Academy of the Holy Angels, Demarest
- The Morristown-Beard School, Morristown
- The Frisch School, Paramus
- Golda Och Academy, West Orange
- Doane Academy, Burlington
- Seton Hall Preparatory School, West Orange
- Villa Victoria Academy, Ewing
- Mount Saint Mary Academy, Watchung
- Pioneer Academy of Science, Wayne
- Saddle River Day School, Saddle River
- Christian Brothers Academy, Lincroft
- Bergen Catholic High School, Oradell
- Noor-Ul-Iman School, Monmouth Junction section of South Brunswick
- Al-Ghazaly High School, Teaneck
- St. Peter’s Preparatory School, Jersey City
- St. Joseph High School, Metuchen
- Torah Academy of Bergen County, Teaneck
- Maayanot Yeshiva High School for Girls, Teaneck
- Bishop Eustace Preparatory School, Pennsauken
- Hillel Yeshiva School, Ocean
- Don Bosco Prep High School, Ramsey
- Trinity Christian School, Montville
- Immaculate Heart Academy, Washington Township
- Academy of Saint Elizabeth, Morristown
- Lacordaire Academy Secondary School, Upper Montclair
- Morris Catholic High School, Denville
- New Jersey United Christian Academy, Cream Ridge
- Union Catholic Regional High School, Scotch Plains
- St. Augustine Preparatory School, Richland
- Eastern Christian High School, North Haledon
- Hawthorne Christian Academy, Hawthorne
- Rav Teitz Mesivta Academy, Elizabeth
- Barnstable Academy, Oakland
- Notre Dame High School, Lawrenceville
- Mount St. Dominic Academy, Caldwell
- Pope John XXIII High School, Sparta
- Immaculata High School, Somerville
- Red Bank Catholic High School, Red Bank
- Hackensack Christian Schools, Hackensack
- Baptist Regional School, Haddon Heights
- Sacred Heart High School, Vineland
- St. Joseph Regional High School, Montvale
- Bruriah High School for Girls, Elizabeth
- Timothy Christian School, Piscataway
- Purnell School, Pottersville
- Paramus Catholic High School, Paramus
- The Pilgrim Academy, Egg Harbor City
- Salem County Christian Academy, Pennsville
- Koinonia Academy, Plainfield
- Bishop George Ahr High School, Edison
- St. John Vianney Regional High School, Holmdel
- Our Lady of Mercy Academy, Newfield
- Camden Catholic High School, Cherry Hill
- Abundant Life Academy, Nutley
- Cumberland Christian School, Vineland
- Gloucester County Christian School, Sewell
- Life Center Academy, Burlington
- Calvary Academy, Lakewood
- Atlantic Christian School, Egg Harbor Township
- Wildwood Catholic High School, North Wildwood
- St. Rose High School, Belmar
- Mater Dei, New Monmouth
- Mother Seton Regional High School, Clark
- Holy Spirit High School, Absecon
- DePaul Catholic High School, Wayne
- Veritas Christian Academy, Sparta
- Holy Cross High School, Delran
- Benedictine Academy, Elizabeth
- St. Mary High School, Rutherford
- Paul VI High School, Haddonfield
- Queen of Peace High School, North Arlington
- St. Dominic Academy, Jersey City
- St. Mary of the Assumption High School, Elizabeth
- Immaculate Conception High School, Lodi
- Marist High School, Bayonne
- St. Patrick High School & Academy, Elizabeth
- St. Joseph Regional High School, Hammonton